Not as good as the first Shari book I read. It dragged on a bit and the ending was a twist no one probably expected. .

I enjoyed Mia and love hearing more on nell's growth still didn't like Ripley but it would have been better if the final battle was more then 1 spell.

This is an excellent start to a new series by Tana French. The two main characters: mysterious teenager Trey Reddy and retired, emotionally scared Cal Hooper are especially appealing. At first Cal doesn't know what to make of Trey. He isn't even certain if she is male or female. She dresses in androgenous clothes and reveals nothing about her life. All he knows is Trey is persistent. Once she learns he was a detective, she is determined to enlist Cal's help in finding her beloved older brother, one of the few people in Trey's life who has shown her kindness. The novel shows the insularity of rural Irish life where villagers close ranks even when something very bad has occurred. This is a wonderful mystery which slowly develops the friendship and trust between Trey, whose home life is blighted by a mother who can barely cope and an absent, ner'do-well father. The ending and the reasons for the "murder" are beyond tragic. The prose is poetic and fitting for the lyricism of the Irish countryside.

I have loved this book since I was three??

This book was phenomenal! I loved it so much!! It was intriguing and kept me on my toes. I couldn’t contain my excitement when I heard of the other books in the trilogy!

It was about Mr. Snail running late to deliver all of the mail. It was good.

It was good.

I don’t like the mean goblins

Goofy saved the parade from catching on fire.

It seemed like something happen hades and persephone didn't actually conversate about it, it was alot of hades did something that hurt her so she did something back to hurt him. It did seem she got a bit better at end of book but was frustrating throughout book. Still going to read next book but I don't know if would reread.